February 08, 2007

DC Council to Consider Public Schools Ombuds

On February 10, the Washington, DC, Council will hold a public hearing on the Public Education Reform Amendment Act of 2007 (which will transfer management and oversight authority of the public schools to the mayor). Among other things, the bill would create an Office of Ombudsman for Public Education. (Washington Post.)

Critics Question Independence of BP Ombuds

In response to allegations that BP substituted water for expensive chemical agents to prevent corrosion in its Prudhoe Bay pipelines, the company ombudsman, retired federal judge Stanley Sporkin, assembled a team of engineers and attorneys to investigate. Unfortunately, Sporkin hired a law firm – Clifford & Garde – with direct ties to BP America chair Robert Malone. Then, Sporkin did not release the results of the investigation. Naturally, this has critics, including the Alaska legislature, questioning Sporkin's independence. (Corporate Crime Reporter.) Sporkin is not a member of IOA.

February 07, 2007

After Bad News From Ombuds, Student Sues UMass

In an attempt to raise questions about grading policies, Brian Marquis filed a lawsuit against the University of Massachusetts. The dispute is over the final grade Marquis received in a philosophy class in Fall 2006. Marquis initially contacted Catharine Porter, the UMass Ombudsperson. He later received an email from Porter that said she had met with the teaching assistant and discussed the final grade scale that resulted in a C. According to her e-mail, professors at UMass can develop their own grading scale. Porter concluded the e-mail by urging Marquis "to accept this grade and continue on with your course work as there were no grounds for an academic grievance." Marquis described this statement as "highly dangerous." UMass administrators declined to comment on the pending litigation. (Daily Collegian.) Just another reminder of how dangerous email can be.
Profile of Texas Tech's Ombuds for Students

Kathryn Quilliam was appointed in 2000 as the first ombudsman for students at Texas Tech. She is the subject of a glowing profile in the campus newspaper. (Daily Toreador.)

February 05, 2007

Resources for Organizations Creating an Ombuds Office

At this point, IOA does not have a package of information for organizations considering an ombuds office. Hopefully, this is something that will become available soon. Until then, I am posting a list of the materials already online (see also column to right):
Surely, there are more resources out there. Let me know what else should be included.
Website for Using Videos to Teach ADR

The Winter 2007 edition of Dispute Resolution Magazine focuses on ADR in film. A special website was created by one of the contributors, Dwight Golann, a mediator and professor at Sufffolk University Law School. There are links to related articles and other resources. (Website.)
Dartmouth Urged to Hire Ombuds

A consortium of senior administrator tasked by Dartmouth President James Wright to address findings by external consultants McKinsey & Co., has recommended the College to create an ombuds office. "Schools as large or larger than Dartmouth usually do have an ombudsperson," said Provost Barry Scherr, chair of the hiring and retention committee. "It will provide a place where people can go with any problem of any size and have it dealt with confidentially." The McKinsey report identified inter-departmental disconnection, error-prone hiring practices and a staff perception of being "undervalued," among other factors, as limiting administrative effectiveness and the retention of promising College employees. (Dartmouth Online.)

January 31, 2007

ABA Dusts Off Its Crystal Ball

Perhaps inspired by Mary Rowe’s prognostication, the American Bar Association has a list of topics lawyers will be discussing in 2007. Some of these could easily be issues for ombuds:
  • Who’s a Citizen? (Immigration reformers want to deny citizenship to “anchor babies”.) – Ombuds will remain a confidential resource for visitors who fear disclosing their immigration status.
  • My Space Discovery (Lawyers are mining social networks for nuggets of evidence) – As virtual communities grow in size and complexity, the number of disputes will increase accordingly. Ombuds will need to adapt to serve visitors with concerns from the virtual domain.
  • Online Background Checks (As social networking grows, so does the ability of employers to discriminate) – Visitors increasingly will have concerns about the blurring of their private life and work life.
  • Medical ID Theft (Sophisticated schemes to get medical records add to the risk facing medical information holders) – Ombuds may expect more cases involving identity theft.
(ABA Journal subscription.)

January 30, 2007

Survey Reveals Recognition is Most Effective Non-Monetary Motivator

According to a survey by Accountemps, frequent recognition of accomplishments is the most effective non-monetary way of motivating employees. Recognition was more important than regular communication, increased responsibility, off-site team-building and social events. "No amount of team-building events or other perks can compensate for a manager personally thanking employees for a job well done," says Max Messmer, chairman of Accountemps. (Business & Legal Reports.) There are many way ombuds can use this seemingly innocuous observation. For example, simply thanking participants at the outset of a facilitation can inspire more dedicated participation in the process.

January 29, 2007

Top Accreditation Official Joins Dept. of Education, FSA Ombuds Office

John W. Barth, director of accreditation and state liaison for the Education Department, abruptly transfered to the Federal Student Aid Ombudsman’s Office. The move was puzzling because the department’s political leaders are engaged in an aggressive campaign to ramp up the government’s oversight of accrediting agencies. (Inside Higher Ed.)

January 26, 2007

NPR Series On Dispute Resolution

National Public Radio's evening program, All Things Considered, is running a series on the pros, cons of bipartisanship. Although "Crossing the Divide" focuses on bipartisanship in Washington, it features examples of compromise and cooperation from business and everyday life that ombuds may find valuable. Recent pieces, which are available for download, discussed:
  • How racial assumptions on both sides keep us from more fully understanding and appreciating "the other";
  • How brothers with deeply opposing political beliefs found common ground and reconciliation; and
  • How former Senators George Mitchell and Alan Simpson moved past partisanship.
(NPR.com.)

January 24, 2007

Sen. Grassley Seeks More Info From CDC Ombuds

Citing "very troubling allegations of serious morale problems" at the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention, Senator Charles Grassley, has asked for additional information on what the agency is doing to address the situation. The ranking Republican on the Senate Finance Committee, sent a letter to CDC Director Julie Gerberding on Tuesday seeking additional information about actions the agency's new ombudsmen are taking to improve the workplace environment at the Atlanta-based agency. (Atlanta Journal Constitution, subscription required; prior Ombuds Blog post.)
More Positive Press for SBA Ombuds

A profile appeared in today's Los Angeles Times featuring Nicholas N. Owens, the new head of the Office of the National Ombudsman at the Small Business Administration. Ownes also announced a two-hour public hearing for small business owners on in Los Angeles. (LA Times.)

January 23, 2007

Job Posting: Cal. State San Bernardino

California State University, San Bernardino is seeking a new Director of Ombuds Services. The incumbent reports directly to the University President and is responsible for "providing impartial and permissible confidential consultation on issues" and functioning as "a communicator and facilitator, as well as a sensor within the campus community to identify problems or trends." So far, so good. In addition, the incumbent is the Equal Employment Opportunity and Diversity Officer, and "will implement and monitor federal Affirmative Action and Equal Employment Opportunity programs to ensure compliance with federal and state regulations, polices, and guidelines." Wha . . . ? . . . sigh. (CSUSB Posting.) The CSUSB Ombuds Office was just founded in March 2006 by Chani Beeman, who previously headed the university's academic computing and media department.
DWS Funds Hires Ombuds

In December 2006, DWS Funds (known until recently as the Scudder Funds), reached a settlement with regulators regarding alleged market-timing arrangements from three years ago. In addition to paying refunds and ensuring better oversight, DWS reportedly has also hired an ombudsman to enable employees to raise ethics questions without fear of retribution from management. (Morningstar.com.)

January 22, 2007

Update: CDC to Make Ombuds Permanent

The director of the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention said Monday the agency will recruit and hire a full-time ombudsman as soon as possible. In an email to all CDC staff, the director said she was pleased with the recent progress reported hours earlier by two interim ombudsmen. (Atlanta Journal Constitution; prior Ombuds Blog post.)
Calif. Appellate Court Relies on Testimony of University Ombuds in Denying Student's Grade Challenge

Stephen Head, a student at California State University, San Jose, had appealed an administrative decision denying his academic grievance which sought a revised grade and alleged that he had been unfairly treated of his conservative politics. In an unpublished decision rejecting the student's claims, the Appellate Court relied on heavily on a declaration from the University Ombudsman Savander Parker that justified the university's handling of the grievance. In fact, Parker appeared to be substantially involved in the grievance process. (Court's Decision.) Parker is a member of IOA.

Update 4/28/10: A similar case, arising out of a grade dispute in 2003, indicated similar testimony from the Ombuds.  (Onkvisit v. Cal. State Pers. Bd., 2010 Cal. App. Unpub. LEXIS 3040 (Apr. 27, 2010).)
"How to" Seminar on Becoming an Ombudsman

ADR Practice Builder has announced a teleseminar on entering the field and having a private consulting practice. The event will take place at 10 am EST on March 29, cost $25 for non-members and feature a to-be-announced special guest. (ADR Practice Builder.)
CDC Ombuds Issue First Report

The two ombudsmen hired in response to morale problems at the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention, Joseph McDade and Gerald Naehr, have received 26 inquiries since last fall, according to an e-mail they sent to agency employees. The ombudsmen (hired last October on a one-year $250,000 contract) have recommended that the CDC establish a permanent ombudsman office at the Atlanta-based agency and hire a full-time director. Senator Charles Grassley, the ranking Republican on the Senate Finance Committee, asked to have the ombudsmen provide him a briefing on their activities by February 9. (Atlanta Journal Constitution subscription required.)

January 19, 2007

Indiana State University Ombuds Dies

Mike Phillips, ISU's student ombudsperson, died Thursday in Terre Haute. He was 61. Phillips was a Terre Haute native and scheduled to retire from his position as student ombudsperson at the end of the spring 2007 semester. As student ombudsperson, Phillips told the Indiana Statesman in August 2002, he was a self-proclaimed "problem solver for any problem a student could have, such as financial aid, housing, roommate, towed car or classroom problems." Phillips is survived by his wife and four children. Funeral arrangements are pending. (Indiana Statesman.) Phillips was a member of IOA.